Danbooru

Tag proposal: oneshota

Posted under Tags

Here's the now deleted wiki for the definition.

It appears this tag has been used in the past, but at some point it was nuked. I've thought about it and tried to search for it and I don't think this can be substituted by any other tag easily without being a pain in the ass. Of course the explicit posts would only show up to users with gold+ so in theory tag limit is not an issue, but that doesn't account for safe posts, and even for someone with no tag search limit it's a pain to find all the results.

For example:
age_difference milf has all kind of unrelated stuff like bestiality, futanari and yuri
age_difference child and age_difference shota are mutually exclusive searches, and an OR search doesn't work because "child" is not gendered. Even here there's several hundred yaoi/yuri/futa results, like for the previous result, which is pretty bad if you're specifically searching for a hetero fetish
age_difference hetero doesn't really work because loli posts make up like 1/3rd of the posts in there. So you'd have to do age_difference hetero -loli, which again doesn't exclude safe female child on male adult posts.

Lastly, age difference is not just child on adult,it could apply to any other random thing like old on adult and other pairs, so it's not a good way to filter for this kind of specific result.

If there's no argument against the tag I'll populate it.

Updated

I would agree with bipface that it be called oneeshota, but at the same time, I feel like I've seen oneshota in Missed Searches more - that, and NNT's point, leads me to agree with his naming suggestion instead.

If nothing else, an alias from one to the other would be useful for the reasons bipface mentions.

I feel like personally I've seen oneshota used reasonably frequently that I think people would figure out what it is. Of course that could just be bias since I know a lot of people into it, and I can read some Japanese. Can also potentially alias straight_shota to it for extra discoverability.

I remember I once petitioned for straight_shota to imply hetero, but it was decided to instead mass update it to hetero+shota, on the case that it was simply a combination of those two tags anyway.
A problem that stemmed from this is that not as many /ss/ pics get tagged hetero as they would have been had the implication gone through (even in the current year, most people seem to forget the hetero tag exists when tagging explicit pics). I would fine with the tag coming back if it has the hetero+shota implication, but just like NNT said, it's probably best to call it oneshota to avoid it being used for shotaxloli pics.
On the naming, if we want to be pedantic, oneshota is the correct spelling instead one oneeshota, since portmanteu causes onee to lose the stretched vowel.

The bulk update request #8701 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create alias oneshota -> onee-shota
create implication onee-shota -> age_difference

Materializing the discussion with a BUR

Going with 'onee-shota' for readability; both 'oneshota' or 'one-shota' would suffer from having an ugly sister effect with 1shota.

  • using rename to move the wiki

Due to it always being a substantial one even in pairings of middle school boy with high school girl where diegetically the age gap could be shorter than 3 years

I'd love to but there is actually quite a lot of oneshota && futanari on pixiv that actually do fit the genre

Updated

I think it wouldn't hurt to alias oneshota to onee-shota instead of rename in this case, its a popular way to refer to this genre, even if onee-shota seems more correct.

ljhkhjkghjybtvhyt said:

I'd love to but there is actually quite a lot of oneshota && futanari on pixiv that actually do fit the genre

There are futanari and newhalf oneshota so it shouldn't imply hetero

ljhkhjkghjybtvhyt said:

Both 'oneshota' or 'one-shota' would suffer from having an ugly sister effect with 1shota.

mongirlfan said:

I think it wouldn't hurt to alias oneshota to onee-shota instead of rename in this case, its a popular way to refer to this genre, even if onee-shota seems more correct.

There are futanari and newhalf oneshota so it shouldn't imply hetero

Agree, both oneshota and oneeshota are bound to be misused, but it's a popular fetish and currently the tag search limit limits its search. Let's see what happens.

1