Posted under Tags
BUR #13868 has been rejected.
create alias milk_carton -> drink_carton
I don't feel like it's necessary to specify if the drink in the carton is milk or not, and sometimes you can't tell like in post #2524157(Q).
Edit: BUR used to include "alias carton -> drink_carton"
Updated
What about juice box? And holding carton vs holding box?
magcolo said:
What about juice box? And holding carton vs holding box?
I didn't realize carton was being used for boxes too. That tag should probably be deprecated, but for now I've just removed it from the BUR.
Juice_box seems to be for the smaller, hand sized cartons that you drink with a straw, so I think it should probably stay a separate tag.
I think the rename is still good given posts with ambiguous cartons and cartons of OJ or whatever.
Tags like milk carton, juice box, soda bottle, water bottle, etc. are all similar in that they indicate a shape or style of container that commonly holds what's indicated in the name but may actually contain something else. I don't think we have to be picky with the names of those tags just because they may be filled with a different drink.
EB said:
Tags like milk carton, juice box, soda bottle, water bottle, etc. are all similar in that they indicate a shape or style of container that commonly holds what's indicated in the name but may actually contain something else. I don't think we have to be picky with the names of those tags just because they may be filled with a different drink.
Fair enough. BUR rejected.
The bulk update request #13868 (forum #228346) has been rejected by @Omo_Fan.
