Blue Archive Clubs Tagging

The bulk update request #14821 has been rejected.

I referred to list of blue archive characters and this site.

First of all I chose posts with the entire club members, and if there were newly registered characters recently, I chose posts with all the previous members.
In some cases, posts include outsiders other than club members.
Clubs with one member was excluded.

Please check the club name to see if it is written correctly and which name suits it better.

P.S Can I modify the BUR request later? If there's anything to change the club name, I'll do it right away.

I strongly dislike - and have made this known in the past - these kind of organization tags. Glancing at your favgroups you're not doing something like a virtual mass update of Tsurugi pics to Justice Comittee, but you can look at tags like team rocket to see that they either get ignored by taggers or just end up on bare ass pics.

If it's a uniform, tag the uniform. If it's a symbol, tag the symbol. Tagging the organiziation, class, company, whatever based purely on whether or not that character is a member of it inevitably ends up being a padding & canon tag.

Veraducks said:

I strongly dislike - and have made this known in the past - these kind of organization tags. Glancing at your favgroups you're not doing something like a virtual mass update of Tsurugi pics to Justice Comittee, but you can look at tags like team rocket to see that they either get ignored by taggers or just end up on bare ass pics.

If it's a uniform, tag the uniform. If it's a symbol, tag the symbol. Tagging the organiziation, class, company, whatever based purely on whether or not that character is a member of it inevitably ends up being a padding & canon tag.

If a club tag is added just by the appearance of one character, maybe all the posts will be plastered with club tags. That's not what I mean.
and If someone uses a club tag on the post of '1girl solo'? That is a complete misunderstanding of this BUR.
What I want is not a club tag hanging on every post like a tag, but to find a combination of people more easily.
It's easy to understand if you think of the tags for the various units in Idolmaster. I made this BUR with that concept in mind.

I don't have a strong opinion on the creation of these tags in general, but I don't think the tags for clubs with only two members are needed. They're just replacing a two tag search. I would also prefer the Global version names of the clubs as the main tags, as they're easier to recognize, especially for the ones that differ more heavily.

blindVigil said:

I don't have a strong opinion on the creation of these tags in general, but I don't think the tags for clubs with only two members are needed. They're just replacing a two tag search.

There are cases where new members are added to clubs that already exist, and also it's a tag that allows you to distinguish them separately with more than two people, so I think it's okay. So guys, please leave your opinions.

blindVigil said:

I would also prefer the Global version names of the clubs as the main tags, as they're easier to recognize, especially for the ones that differ more heavily.

modified to global version.

AkaringoP said:

If a club tag is added just by the appearance of one character, maybe all the posts will be plastered with club tags. That's not what I mean.
and If someone uses a club tag on the post of '1girl solo'? That is a complete misunderstanding of this BUR.
What I want is not a club tag hanging on every post like a tag, but to find a combination of people more easily.
It's easy to understand if you think of the tags for the various units in Idolmaster. I made this BUR with that concept in mind.

There are tons of 1girl solo pics with the Idolmaster costume set tags. In the group set tags, if you search for images of just the constituent characters, you'll find that about half of any given group is not tagged with the group despite clearly being marked as the group. And the costume set tags should probably be broken down into individual chartags or renamed to make them more clear that they're for uniforms. We did the former with similar tags from Fate and Fire Emblem, like Lostroom Outfit.

Veraducks said:

There are tons of 1girl solo pics with the Idolmaster costume set tags.

This BUR is not a topic for costume tags. It's no wonder that costume tags are used for 1girl posts.

I think the group(unit?, club? Whatever..) tag is determined by characters of the unit, not by just looking at the outfit they are wearing. As you mentioned, the tag for the costume needs to be modified with a tag such as '*_(costume)_(idolmaster).

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #14821 (forum #231984) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.