Posted under Tags
BUR #22847 has been rejected.
create alias narrowed_eyes -> half-closed_eyes
I can't understand the difference between these two labels. I think they should describe the same thing. If you object, it's best to tell me the difference between these two labels.
WaterMiner said:
BUR #22847 has been rejected.
create alias narrowed_eyes -> half-closed_eyes
I can't understand the difference between these two labels. I think they should describe the same thing. If you object, it's best to tell me the difference between these two labels.
I think the narrowed eyes tag should be gardened first. I see some posts such as (post #7044485) that appear to show naturally narrow eyes. Some users may be interpreting "narrowed" as a passive verb instead of an active verb and adding the tag to those posts.
I also think we might want to have a more specific amount of eye closure defined for half-closed_eyes. This is just my opinion and not necessarily reflective of current usage, but I think the tag should be used when you can see a significant amount of eyelid (post #7131982), but not when there's so little you can't tell if the eyes are actually partially closed (post #7145148).
Updated by Blank User
Blank_User said:
I think the narrowed eyes tag should be gardened first. I see some posts such as (post #7044485) that appear to show naturally narrow eyes. Some users may be interpreting "narrowed" as a passive verb instead of an active verb and adding the tag to those posts.
I also think we might want to have a more specific amount of eye closure defined for half-closed_eyes. This is just my opinion and not necessarily reflective of current usage, but I think the tag should be used when you can see a significant amount of eyelid (post #7131982), but not when there's so little you can't tell if the eyes are actually partially closed (post #7145148).
but I think the tag should be used when you can see a significant amount of eyelid (post #7131982)
Actually, I don't really agree with this, in most of the paintings I've seen, there are rare instances where the author will have painted eyelids, and I think that, if judged by that standard, probably the vast majority of labels would be mislabeled. Also, I think it could be proposed that works with painted eyelids in the image be labeled with an eyelid (as an element, it's just so unique, isn't it?)
I've seen these tags used for two distinct things, with half-closed eyes being for the heavy-lidded, relaxed (perhaps sleepy) expression like post #7226861, and narrowed eyes for more intentional expressions without that heavy-lidded expression (e.g. post #6423011) often with distinct intentional muscle activation behind the expression (or alongside v-shaped eyebrows or furrowed brows).
The bulk update request #22847 (forum #266952) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.
