Should we keep ochako_uraraka_(hero_outfit)?

BUR #26976 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

nuke ochako_uraraka_(hero_outfit)

Tag made without any discussion lets have a trial by fire to see if it lives.

BUR #26977 has been rejected.

remove alias uravity_(boku_no_hero_academia) -> uraraka_ochako
create alias ochako_uraraka_(hero_outfit) -> uravity_(boku_no_hero_academia)

Alternative to keep it, but match how we handle other superheroes and alter egos.

zetsubousensei said:

BUR #26977 has been rejected.

remove alias uravity_(boku_no_hero_academia) -> uraraka_ochako
create alias ochako_uraraka_(hero_outfit) -> uravity_(boku_no_hero_academia)

Alternative to keep it, but match how we handle other superheroes and alter egos.

Related topic #19101

Could go either way on the nuke as there's some value in tagging distinct alternate costumes, but uraraka_ochako superhero_costume should suffice for most purposes.

It's worth noting there's only like one post of another character wearing her outfit. It could be valuable as a gentag for that, if there were more. It would be distinct from the broader uraraka (cosplay) tag.

Also, the name order on this tag is wrong. The character is uraraka ochako. Everyone in this series goes by their family name, so it can get confusing.

BUR #27025 has been rejected.

rename ochako_uraraka_(hero_outfit) -> uraraka_ochako_(hero_outfit)

Whether we keep the tag or make it an alias, the name order will still need to be changed as LQ said, so let's take care of that first.

LQ said:

Could go either way on the nuke as there's some value in tagging distinct alternate costumes, but uraraka_ochako superhero_costume should suffice for most purposes.

It's worth noting there's only like one post of another character wearing her outfit. It could be valuable as a gentag for that, if there were more. It would be distinct from the broader uraraka (cosplay) tag.

Uraraka ochako (cosplay) is barely over two pages long. For it to actually be worth making a general tag specifically for cosplays of her superhero outfit, it would need hundreds of posts like sugoi dekai. Even then, uraraka_ochako_(cosplay) superhero_costume should suffice.

Also the cosplay tag is nothing but people wearing her outfit, what are you looking at that there's only one?

I only looked at ochako_uraraka_(hero_outfit) cosplay in this case (outfit -character is understandably empty), but obviously the new tag is small

yeah, something like crisis management form (machimazo) has several hundred posts

The bulk update request #26976 (forum #283566) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #26977 (forum #283567) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #27025 (forum #283694) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.

If we want to have special tags for hero outfits it must be done for all characters and after a forum discussion, not as a one-off half-assed population with the wrong name order.