Posted under General
This is the fourth time someone's brought up pool #2459 without thinking about it. Just because someone's brought up a pool before doesn't mean it's magically more deletable because you are pissed it exists. We have already justified why it continues to exist.
I could find the posts but because you're so gung-ho about deleting things I leave it up to you.
Since you can't post these justifications, I'll have to assume that you have no idea what you are talking about.
You probably mean the first time it was brought up (page 31 ). Back then, there wasn't any way to tag a "parody of the source material style with the source material." . However, since we now have official style, the pool is completely pointless.
And yes, if a pool is posted here multiple times by multiple users, there is probably a good reason for that. Even more so because users who post here nearly never get any feedback as to why the pools are not deleted. As I said before, if a pool needs more than 3 posts of discussion, it probably stays no matter how pointless it is. And when I make a thread specifically about it, I get huge support even from mods. It's just diffusion of responsibility.
Just look at the list of pools and tell my why you think they shouldn't be deleted.
If something is not deleted the first time it's not out of apathy it's because a good enough reason hasn't been posted. If you manage to somehow post the best logic in the world ever about deleting each and every one of those pools I will delete them all. I already deleted one because it hadn't expanded beyond when it was first posted.
I'm not convinced that a tag rantuyetmai created with no discussion is a replacement for a pool, regardless of it's population.
How does official style + rating:e not replace the pool? Lack of discussion vigilante tag or not, controversial pool or not, that tag combination makes the pool redundant.
pool #2813 - Touhou - Houraisan Kaguya - The Neet Princess
Since I just found this while searching the forum
ShadowbladeEdge said in forum #55178:
I think the Neet Princess pool should get the axe while we're at it.
BTW, also read rantuyetmai's post just above ShadowbladeEdge's. It reflects the state we are currently in concerning the "character x does y" pools.
There is a neet tag, albeit only with 61 posts. 45 of those are already Kaguya. In other words, the tag and pool are both about neet kaguya, but the tag allows for other characters. If we just tag all the images in the pool neet (except for the last one. even the pool creator knows that it shouldn't be in there), we can delete the pool.
Log said:
I'm not convinced that a tag rantuyetmai created with no discussion is a replacement for a pool, regardless of it's population.
May I inform you that the pool in question hasn't been discussed in the forum either?
Updated
pool #4731 Touhou - Mazeran Touhou Persona
Mazeran Touhou Persona
Rampardos said:
pool #4731 Touhou - Mazeran Touhou Persona
Mazeran Touhou Persona
It's a clearly-defined series of images by one artist. By that logic, we should delete all comic pools from artists who only have one comic, because you can find them with an (artist) comic search.
pool #4788 - delicious thighs
curvy, full, voluptuous thighs. complimented nicely by curvy hips, a nice waist, short skirts and panties, though the focus is thighs. a mostly subjective pool.
seems like a favorites pool and not very different to the Hot/Perfect pools which are about to be nuked as discussed in forum #69115
Updated
Yeah, the thick_thighs tag should cover this.
pool #4796 - Perfect Penises
Pool of particularly picturesque peckers. Should be uncensored (or as good as) and fully visible, but not necessarily male.
the very first post in forum #69115 particularly mentioned this type of pool and the way i understood it prevents its creation.
S1eth said:
pool #4639 - Touhou - Youkai Extermination Sanae
Way to take it too far.
Yokai extermination was one of Sanae's reasons for being a playable character in UFO. This led to a rash of images of her being evil or crazy and to a meme of her bullying Kogasa. All in contrast to the previous "good girl" meme.
While the pool needs a little cleanup (and more examples), many of the images that have text explicitly referring to youkai extermination, and it serves as a way of unifying a theme that is quite hard to tag as you've demonstrated. Oppose deletion.
It's ridiculous how every touhou character gets their own pool lately. (Aya even has 2, Yukari has 3)
Edit: Kyubey has 4 whole pools
Not a cause for concern, IMHO. Touhou makes up approximately 20-25% of the images on this site. It's got a fandom that spawns many memes, and keeping track of them is useful, especially when tags don't cut it.
Kyubey is just a memetic machine and earns his pools, IMHO.
Reminder (pools mentioned earlier that are still here for some reason):
pool #4169 - Touhou - The Yakumo Family
pool #4440 - Touhou - The Moriya Family
Support if and only if an effort is made to go through those pools and add appropriate images into Family Bonding, pool #2140.
pool #2459 - Panty & Stocking - In-Style Erotica
3 tag search. Not good for mortal users. Oppose deletion.
pool #4347 - Ears off!
Support deletion, but I'd like to see a tag replace it.
pool #4025 - Masturbating at the Computer
Weakly oppose. You could do a few overlapping 2-tag searches as a mere mortal user, but I think it unifies a theme pretty well, and it's not hard to tell what should or shouldn't go in it. I'd support it if computer_keyboard & computer_mouse both implicate computer.
I support deletion of the rest.
Regarding pool #2193 (though I'm well informed that it is based on Pixiv tag),
Can we just use the tags touhou + dark_persona and/or corruption instead?
We can for all of them except for post #1023845. She doesn't appear like a very DARK persona to me.
I've removed all images that are not part of the project (lack the tag on pixiv).
Pool describes a tag, no description and one picture.
pool #3378. Aa... Natsukashi no Heroine-tachi!!
This is just a pool for a copyright that's covered by the tag nostalgic_heroines.
Side note: Is the search nostalgic_heroines -pool:3378 supposed to work? I just used pool:3378 -nostalgic_heroines to tag the remaining untagged pics, but when I tried to check the inverse, the -pool:# search term had no effect.
just a question but wasn't pool #4731 nuked last time?
edit: just saw the one posted 9 days ago... but I'll put my opinion it needs to go.
