isn't this really bad anatomy though? Nice pic overall
I didn't see anything too glaringly off about Alice's anatomy or the dolls. Yuyuko is a different story, but as a minor chibified doodle, that shouldn't qualify for bad_anatomy. What were you referring to?
D1ce said: I didn't see anything too glaringly off about Alice's anatomy or the dolls. Yuyuko is a different story, but as a minor chibified doodle, that shouldn't qualify for bad_anatomy. What were you referring to?
I think he is talking about Alice's legs - too thin and for me looks like knees too low.
I'm not disputing that Alice's appearance seems somewhat off. I think her shoulders should have been drawn slightly wider, her legs shorter, and her torso a little taller. Should this post be tagged with bad_anatomy? Maybe. And maybe not.
As of this writing, the wiki entry for bad_anatomy does not explicitly define guidelines for its use. Searching the tag results mostly in images featuring subjects with one or more visibly obvious or glaringly bad (i.e., severely disproportionate) body parts such as too small of a head, a giant leg, etc. The reason I do not think bad_anatomy would apply here is because Alice is clothed neck-to-foot in layers of clothing that obfuscate most of her body shape, although her visible appendages appear to fall within the "norm." Yes, it seems indisputable that she is depicted tall and thin; perhaps the long_legs tag could be also used. Why do her knees appear so low and her torso short? It could be bad anatomy on the artist's part. An alternative explanation could be that her skirt is pulled up high. Perhaps this is traditional attire or based on it, and this is how she is supposed to appear. Perhaps this is the "artist's style." If one of those cases is true, then this may not be an example of bad anatomy. The tagging guideline of "tag what you see, not what you know" advises against tagging on speculation such as this. Since this post is certainly not lacking in tags (130+), and since bad_anatomy appears to be used to highlight badly drawn, clearly visible body parts, I feel that it does not apply here.
Maybe I'm reading into the tag the wrong way. If you still think the tag should be added, then feel free to click Edit and add it.
Aya is in the window, Yuyuko is printed on the milk carton.
I thought that Aya was a kuma... -W-'
Age:
secret
RanguageAya ShameimaruAlice MargatroidIn the streetAloneRanguage, as the author most likely meant to write "single" rather then "lonely".Milk
