At first, there was something bugging me about the one with Keine, but then HOLY CRAP FLANDRE. By the time I recovered, I'd completely forgotten what it was.
Too much despair is in all of the eyes... way too much. Patchy looks like an idiot (no offense meant here. Just my opinion), Reimu's smile is too broad...
Only Marisa, Remilia, Shikieiki, Youmu and maybe Flan (though not quite sure) are okay... DO NOT WANT...
Bad apple colored seems to me like an heavy case of "totally missing the point"
I agree, as far as it comes to the actual animation.
However, I would love to see more colored stills inspired by various scenes of "Bad Apple!!", made in various styles and media, yet so that you recognize the connection.
The pics above are a bit too generic in average, but I do like many of them.
To be perfectly clear on this point: The animation cannot be colored/textured because it involves transitions between objects of similar shape but entirely different color/texture. How would you expect the space between Yukari and Tenshi to transform into Aya's wing without the advantage of monochrome? It's not just missing the point to ask, but asking for the impossible.
I noticed that as well. It doesn't even match the original video. In it, Keine had a "normal" sized posterior, and Ex-Keine had a "poofy" dress and not an abnormally sized posterior. This is a case of either Artist failure or not caring.