Missing brooch implications

Posted under Tags

BUR #43739 is pending approval.

create implication aqua_brooch -> brooch
create implication bat_brooch -> brooch
create implication black_brooch -> brooch
create implication blue_brooch -> brooch
create implication brown_brooch -> brooch
create implication butterfly_brooch -> brooch
create implication clover_brooch -> brooch
create implication diamond-shaped_brooch -> brooch
create implication green_brooch -> brooch
create implication grey_brooch -> brooch
create implication orange_brooch -> brooch
create implication pink_brooch -> brooch
create implication purple_brooch -> brooch
create implication rabbit_brooch -> brooch
create implication red_brooch -> brooch
create implication shell_brooch -> brooch
create implication skull_brooch -> brooch
create implication waist_brooch -> brooch
create implication white_brooch -> brooch
create implication yellow_brooch -> brooch

Covering colored brooches, and various brooches with at least 100 posts. If I can populate other shapes to that benchmark, I'll consider adding requests for them too.

I do think that diamond brooch needs some cleanup, since several posts appear to have been mistagged from diamond-shaped brooch. I kept it out of the BUR for this reason until the tag can be tightened up some more. Perhaps it could be renamed to diamond gem brooch or something more intuitive to avoid confusion?

For the colored brooches, I also added the line, "If it is clearly made out of a gem, consider adding (color)_gemstone as well" in case the brooch's material can be clearly made out as a gem.

Related topic #20275.

A few weeks ago, I wanted to propose an implication BUR and an opposing update&nuke BUR for voting purposes, regarding the color of brooches. But forum #206077 confused me and I didn’t know how to properly write the second BUR.

Do brooches always have gemstones or not? The wiki says "typically", then I read that forum which left me stumped.

Updated by aster1a

I would think that brooches can be made from different materials like glass, colored stones, metal, or maybe even plastic if it’s designed to be a toy. It doesn’t exclusively have to be gemstones, so the colored brooches could cover those other materials that would be next to impossible to identify in an image.

AngryZapdos said:

This feels like tagging colors on wristwatches, or necklaces. I really don't think it's necessary and I'd much prefer to see the color_brooch tags done away with.

I would argue brooches are more prominent (usually bigger too) in designs than necklaces (specifically thinking of brooches as/on neckwear) which makes them closer to tagging neck ribbon colors.

1