NootDoot said:
While I admit there is room for improvement but part of it is style related. The other point there is, if everything applies to both, then why is one still allowed
because it was posted 12 years ago, like Kittey said, standards of quality then were much lower than now, and everyone on the site has better things to do than hunt for incredibly old posts just to flag them for the sake of comparison, especially as older posts logically get seen less.
And i wouldn't say part of the issue with abukumacl's work is style related, style isn't a real factor in overall quality when it's still beginner-stage learning.
Don't want to make an unfair comparison, and 4 out of 5 posts are approved, but a case of style actually being a detrimental factor in how likely the art is to get approved is inputwo's stuff, here that's someone who knows exactly what they're doing, i'd say they're expert-level in art, but i wouldn't be surprised if i started posting their art here with half of the posts not getting approved
And if i have to take some of my posts for comparison then samipeko seems, at least to me, to be another case of style just not sitting well on this site as there is a lot of good points about their art, in line quality, sense of anatomy, and even how dynamic even the most static poses end up looking.